[ Another remake of a story that was deleted. Hopefully it’s a good as the one you may remember. <33 ]
It was me, my sister, her boyfriend, and few other friends sitting in the hot tub, and a few of the guys sitting on the edge with only their feet in, because we had so many people in the hot tub. I didn’t usually hang out with my sister and her friends, but my sister had allowed me to join them.
“Truth” I said, everyone collectively groaning and booing me, teasing me for not having chosen a dare.
“Natalie,….” my sisters best friend said glaring at me as if she was about to ask me a difficult question.
“Yes?” I asked with a giggle as she tapped her chin, pretending to think of a question.
My sister seemed annoyed that she had let me join them as she rolled her eyes and turned to her boyfriend, and started to kiss him, using an excessive amount of tongue. I watched her boyfriend Jake pull back and brush her off, telling her to “chill”.
I focused my attention back to my sisters best friend Erica.
“Are you a virgin?” Erica smiled while cocking her head.
My sister scoffed. “Of course she is..” she said, at the same time I gave my answer of “No.”
My sister jerked her head. “Youre lying.” she rolled her eyes.
I looked at her. “No…I’m not lying…” I said giving my sister attitude.
“Since when?” she asked.
“Since a few months after dating Jeff” I said. Jeff was my recent ex.
“You had sex with Jeff?” my sister asked as if she didnt believe me.
“Yes.” I answered.
Jake my sisters boyfriend was looking at my sister. “The girl said yes. She answered the question. Your turn Nat” he said, trying to shut up my sister.
“I just find that extremely hard to believe…” my sister said. I wasnt sure if she was trying to insult me, or if she was just trying to embarrass me, or what, but she was a bitch naturally. So, it wasn’t a shock.
“Why is it hard to believe?” I asked.
She laughed with a scoff. “You didn’t even know what DP was” she laughed, recalling back to earlier that year when her and Erica were talking about how my sister had let two guys DP her at some party.
I rolled my eyes and got defensive. She was trying to make me look stupid.
“Well…not ALL of us know SO much about it….” I said glaring at her, a collective, quiet “ooooooooo” came from the people in the hot tub.
She gave me a look, as if I shouldnt dare say another word. But she had brought it on herself.
“I mean…I suppose if I got drunk at parties….and let two guys fuck my ass and pussy at the same time…I’d have known what it was…but I guess…Im just stupid” I said shrugging sarcastically. Erica, my sisters best friend leaned her head back and widened her eyes as if about to prepare for a shit storm.
I watched her boyfriend Jake look at her. “When was this?” he asked.
I watched my sister place her hand on his shoulder. “Babe she wasnt talking about me” she said. Jake didn’t believe her, I knew he didn’t because he knew better. My sister had cheated on him several times, he only knew of two times. But had let them go, cause he cheated too when they first started dating.
“Truth or Dare Rachel.” I said almost in a growl, staring at my sister.
My sister shot me a look.
“Dare” she said. So smug, thinking she was getting away with avoiding being exposed by a truth.
“I dare you to tell us all who the last guy you slept with was.” I glared at her.
“Jake” she answered quickly. “Duh” she laughed nervously. I saw the panic set in. She knew what I was doing, and she knew that I knew, just last night she had snuck a guy into the house while she thought everyone was asleep. I heard them fucking.
“Now who’s a liar?” I asked. Dead silence in the hot tub.
“What the hell Rachel?” Jake looked at her.
“Oh come on, clearly she is lying!” Rachel shrieked. “Babe! She’s lying!” she said as Jake pushed himself away from her and moved over to the other side of the hot tub.
“Oh my god, whatever…fine if you dont believe me! “ my sister said standing up. “Fuck you Jake. Fuck you Natalie.” she said looking at me as she got out of the hot tub. And stormed off. Like she always does when she’s wrong.
Erica got up and followed my sister into the house.
“sorry.” I said to Jake, the rest of the hot tub still silent looking around. “I made it awkward”
“no …youre sister did…cause shes a fucking bitch” one of her friends said. Everyone laughed a little.
I looked to Jake. “Sorry…” I said.
He sighed. “no..i fucking knew it…and i knew better than to give her another chance….i was already pretty sure of it….Marcus right?” he asked.
I shrugged. “I didnt see who it was…”
He shook his head. “What a bitch” he murmured.
“Take your turn again Natalie..” one of the girls said.
We slowly got back into the game. Everyone laughing as we all dared one another, and exposed some ridiculous, and also some private truths. We had made it through enough rounds to where, every girl except myself had been dared to flash her tits, or kiss one of the other girls. One of them had their top off completely, she was dared to keep it off for the rest of the game.
“Natalie….truth or dare” one of the guys asked me.
“Dare” I giggled, feeling brave. I had only chosen truths at that point.
“I dare you to make out with Jake for two minutes, while straddling him.” he said , the girls gasping and giggling and the other guys hooting and hollering.
“I dont think that’s a good idea..” I said.
“what happens in the hot tub…stays in the hot tub” the guy said. “ your sister wont know”
Jake looked to me and smirked. “It’s just a game.”
I was hesitant but moved through the water and onto his lap, feeling his hands grab my waist and pull me on to him and the bubbles around us seemed to roar louder. My heart was beating fast. I’d always had a secret crush on him, just a little one. and I bit my lip looking down at him as he grinned.
“you dont have to if you dont want..” he said quietly. I lowered myself down and pushed my mouth to his.
“oh my god!” I heard one girl giggle.
I could feel him smile against my lips and his hands automatically slide up my sides and back down, pulling me into him a little more. I parted my mouth slightly, and we started to use tongue. My hands had made their way to his face and it had only taken less than seconds for it to become intense. I couldnt help but roll my hips, grinding on him slightly as his hands held my hips.
I could hear the other people in the hot tub chatter, laugh, encourage us both as we continued to make out.
Jakes hands were up my back , sliding over the strings that tied my bikini top on, and then sliding back down my back. I moaned slightly in his mouth, and heard his friend start to count down the last 10 seconds.
I felt his hands grip me tighter, as if the two minutes was too long, and he didnt want to stop. Neither did I. And we both voluntarily blocked out his friend hitting the “zero” mark of the countdown. Both of us continuing to make out, rolling my hips on him, grinding him still. I didnt give a shit about my sister in that moment. I didnt feel bad at all.
“Okay you two!” One of the girls yelled, laughing. “Times up!”
I pulled back and looked at Jake as he opened his eyes, smiling up at me, and grinning, grabbing my face and pulling my mouth back to his. I kissed him again, our tongues back at one anothers. I giggled slightly as one of the girls said “oh brother! Game is over! These two cant stop! “
I pulled back again, and Jakes hands grabbed me pulling me hard against his cock, making me grind him, I could feel it hard in the water, in his swim trunks, I bit my lip.
“Oh boy” said the girl. “You two finished now?”
I smiled at Jake and nodded. He grinned and his hands lingered on my legs as I moved off him to sit back in my spot.
“Just stay on his lap…then I can sit in the hot tub” said the guy who dared me, taking my spot on the side of the hot tub I was sitting on.
“What?” I laughed. “No.”
“finders keepers” said the guy with a shrug.
I felt Jakes hands on my waist and pull me down onto him. I giggled and the girls did too. Nobody really seeming to care about my sister or what she would think. But I guess that’s because she was as much of a bitch to them, as she was to me.
“your turn” Jake said his one hand on my tummy, the other on the side of my leg.
I took my turn and decided to payback the guy who dared me to make out with Jake, by daring him to streak around the pool until we tell him to stop.
He laughed. “If you wanna see my dick, just say so!” he said jokingly and everyone laughed as he got out of the hot tub.
Everyone watched him as he got out of the tub. their eyes on him, everyone moving to lean up against the side of the tub nearest the pool. I went to move too , but Jake pulled me back, and as I turned my head to look at him, he grinned.
“What?” I said laughing, looking back to the others that were crowded on the other side of the hot tub, hanging over it, or standing behind those hanging over it and looking to the guy pretending to do a sexy dance in the yard before removing his trunks. I giggled watching him, and felt Jake scoot me forward on his lap just a little and then felt him lift his body up. I looked behind me, and saw his hands at his sides, then felt the fabric of his shorts being pushed down, and he quickly pulled me back. I felt him pull at my bikini bottoms, moving them to the side. I didnt stop him, and only helped him as he guided the head of his cock near my pussy. Neither of us said a thing as I uncomfortably lowered my pussy carefully, the water washing away the natural lubrication of my pussy, making it harder for him to just slide right in.
I yelped slightly as his dick finally pushed it was into me, almost all of it on the first push.
“Oh god” I heard him groan., and his hands were on my hips, and he thrust the rest of himself up inside me. I wanted to moan out. It hurt, but it felt good. It felt good to have my sisters boyfriends cock inside me while her friends were right there, nobody knowing that he was fucking me.
I raised myself up slowly, and then back down, fucking in the water was terribly uncomfortable but I liked it anyways. I bit my lip as Jake thrust upwards, the water in the hot tub making slight waves as he thrusted, nobody really noticing or paying attention. Except for Derrick, the one I had dared to run around the yard naked. He noticed exactly what we were doing as he was the only one facing us, but, he didnt want to expose us, he wanted his best friend to enjoy his girlfriends younger sister.
My mouth fell open as Jake thrust harder. I looked to Derrick as I held in my moans, he was distracting them even more as he shook his ass at them and took of his shorts and started to run around the yard on that side.
I bit my lips together, feeling Jake’s hips push up, as he pulled me down as hard as he could, also trying to ride him as I sat on his lap the water making impossible for either of us to go as fast as we wanted.
I looked to my sisters window at the back of our house, her bedroom light on and grinned to myself. This is what you get bitch, I thought to myself as Jake kept fucking me.
He groaned, very quietly, that barely I could even here, and I could tell he had started to cum. I didn’t even care. I kept working myself as good as I could as I watched derrick finish almost his last lap around the yard.
Jake stopped me, holding himself inside me and then slowly guided me off his cock and gently to his side. He leaned his head back. “Fuck…” he said quietly and then turned to look at me.
“You have no idea how many times Ive thought about that.” he said smiling with a laugh, and throwing his head back again. “Oh god…” he said. “That was so fucking hot. “ he said looking at me again.
“It was” I said with a smile.
“I never knew you were that kind of girl Natalie.” he grinned.
“Me either” I said. he laughed.
“I think i’ve been dating the wrong sister.” he joked.
I shrugged. “Just having sex with the wrong one,” I said with a small laugh.
He laughed again and nodded. “I concur”
One of the girls turned around as me and Jake stared at one another, everyone else following suit as Derrick returned to the hot tub, leaving his shorts on the lawn. Everyone laughing.
Jake leaned into my ear. “You should come stay the night at my place tonight..”
I turned and looked at him with a laugh. “Yeah…ok”
He grinned. “Im serious…you can tell your sister and parents youre going to a friends house…”
I looked at him and bit my lip.
“I need to have more of you” he said quietly in my ear. I giggled, and noticed a few people watching us.
“Ok.” I said , agreeing to it. So he’d stop drawing attention to us with whispers in my ear.
He whispered in my ear again. “Go get your stuff ready….ill meet you out front in 15 minutes”
I looked to him. “right now?” I asked.
He grinned and nodded, but then shook his head as he told me. “I cant wait”